Puck is the goalkeeper of FC Utrecht. The Dutch/Canadian goalkeeper transferred in the summer of 2023 from AZ Alkmaar to the Utrecht football club. Previously, Puck played for VV Saestum, the club she had been with since 2020 and won the championship of the Dutch Topklasse with, as well as in Canada for the University of Victoria and Victoria Highlanders. The goalkeeper has been part of the 'team of the year' multiple times in Canada.